A Quick And Early Look At The Northwest Division Rivals
NHL.com has just listed the Canucks as one of their top 10 teams on the rise, saying:
Losing Mattias Ohlund could hurt, but that was buried under the important re-signings of the Sedin twins. Roberto Luongo is at the top of his game and will be motivated by the opportunity to get hot and start for Canada in the Olympics. Alex Burrows, Ryan Kesler, Kevin Bieksa and Alexander Edler only are getting better. Mikael Samuelsson, signed away from the Detroit Red Wings can make the power play better.
Convincing, huh? No not really. However, are the Canucks really worse off on paper than last year? Not really. I just find it odd that the writer calls them a team on the rise when they already won the Northwest Division title. Alas, you never know what can happen, and so many variables are involved (like what division rivals are doing in the off season).
Note: No other Northwest Division teams made the list.
Here's a quick look at how the other teams in our division are shaping up this summer. NOTE: **Yes, every other team in the NW has made a coaching change, as the guys quickly reminded me)** But I'm just focusing on the player additions.
CALGARY FLAMES
IN: D Jay Bouwmeester, F Fredrick Sjostrom
OUT: D Adrian Aucoin, F Todd Bertuzzi, F Mike Cammalleri, D Anders Eriksson, F Jamie Lundmark, F Warren Peters, F Andre Roy, D Rhett Warrener
Cap Spending: $54.29 million
Adding the coveted Bouwmeester meant that the Flames had to part ways with Mike Cammalleri. They have so much money invested in Bouwmeester, Phaneuf, Jokinen, Iginla and Kiprusoff that they can spend no more. They are now thick on D and more shallow up front. I still think the addition of Olli Jokinen at the deadline was a joke, yet he may rack up the points this year as he plays more with the team. Who knows. Glad they have him and not us.
Better or Worse? Potentially worse. Secondary scoring may be quite tough to come by beyond Iginla, Jokinen and Langkow.
EDMONTON OILERS
IN: G Nicolai Khabibulin
OUT: F Ales Kotalik, G Dwayne Roloson, G Dany Sabourin, D Jason Strudwick
Cap Spending: $51.40 million.
Not much change here except between the pipes, where Khabibulin may be an upgrade over Dwayne Roloson. I say "may be" because the Oilers are a run and gun team. Khabby is going to see a lot more quantity and quality shots in Edmonton. Let's see how he fares with that.
Edmonton's fate lies with the health of Sheldon Souray and Lubomir Visnovsky. They have over $13 million invested in those 2 defencemen. Madness I say. Up front they have a lot of young guys who may find their stride after sophomore seasons and what-not.
Are they going to add Dany Heatley or not? He could change the Coilers' fortunes.
Better or Worse? About the same.
MINNESOTA WILD
IN: F Martin Havlat, potentially F Kyle Brodziak (RFA), D Greg Zanon, G Wade Dubielwicz
OUT: D Marc-Andre Bergeron, D Kurtis Foster, F Marian Gaborik, F Krys Kolanos, F Corey Locke, F Bryan Lundbohm, D Tomas Mojzis, G Nolan Schaefer, D Jesse Schultz, D Martin Skoula, F Stephane Veilleux,
Cap Spending: $51.43 million
I am still laughing at the Wild letting injury-prone Marian Gaborik go and then acquiring injury-prone Martin Havlat. I don't care if Havlat played 81 games last season. Look at his track record. Plus it was a contract year. Let's start placing bets on how many games he plays this year. I'll start the betting with 55 games.
The Wild need more help up front, and they may just get that as trading Josh Harding is imminent.
Better or Worse? Worse
COLORADO AVALANCHE
IN: D Tom Preissing, D Kyle Quincey, G Craig Anderson, and Potentially 1st Round Draft Pick Matt Duchene
OUT: F Tyler Arnason, F Jesse Boulerice, F Ben Guite, F Ian Laperriere, F Matt Hendricks, F Per Ledin, D Aaron MacKenzie, D Lawrence Nycholat, G Andrew Raycroft, F Joe Sakic, F Nathan Smith, D Daniel Tjarnqvist, F Brian Willsie, F Cody McCormick
Cap Spending: $49.71 million
It's all about rebuilding for the Avalanche. especially up front. The goaltending and defence are set and more experienced. Canucks fans may get a good look at Matt Duchene, a former teammate of Cody Hodgson. It will be a mighty surprise if the Avalanche make the playoffs this year, but at least they are taking the right steps. Losing Sakic's presence will hurt, just as it did last season, but at least they have an upgrade in goal adding Craig Anderson.
Better or Worse? A bit better. They can't be any worse than last year's 69 points.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Considering how often we play these teams each year I'm feeling optimistic. But you can never take any of these teams for granted. The Canucks are going to have to play better against lesser teams than they did last year.
Like I said, this is a quick and early look at these teams. They still have lots of summer left to tinker with their rosters.
0 recs |
20 comments
|
Comments
Good analysis. A couple of notes:
Lundmark was re-signed by Cgy and they added Nigel Dawes. Dawes might have success reunited with Sutter.
Strudwick was re-signed by Edm.
Screw Lundmark and Dawes. The big acquisition you’re missing for the flamers is Jaffray! Zan, how could you?
by Beantown Canuck on Jul 21, 2009 3:18 AM PDT up reply actions
Ugh, I have no faith that Jaffray is going to get a clear shot with an NHL team anymore.
by Sean Zandberg on Jul 21, 2009 8:15 AM PDT up reply actions
With their recent signings, the Flames have a great deal of bottom six guys. I still think they’re the team to beat, but it has more to do with canning Keenan than any signings.
Similarly, I expect better things out of Edmonton with Quinn there. They have a decent crop of forwards and Khabibulin is definitely an upgrade to Roloson (though they still overpaid).
Minnesota needs some work on the back end too which is shame since their goalie is so good. He needs some better support all around but, again, new coach so who knows. Maybe there’s more than meets the eye there.
Colorado needs one more season in the tank before the become what the BJ’s and St. Louis were last year (or what the Kings could be this year). but, boy, will they miss Nathan Smith and Raycroft.
'Nucks Misconduct - Housing Swedish Millionaires Since 2000.
Funny enough, all those teams have new coaches. I just wanted to focus on the players…. should have clarified that.
by Sean Zandberg on Jul 21, 2009 8:14 AM PDT up reply actions
That’s fair, but a good point still. And all of those coaches needs to go (with the exception of Granato who should never been there anyway). I expect the Flames to be the winner just because they lose Keenan and his particular special style of play.
'Nucks Misconduct - Housing Swedish Millionaires Since 2000.
by Yankee Canuck on Jul 21, 2009 9:03 AM PDT up reply actions
I don’t think Khubi in for Roloson is an upgrade. If they make the playoffs, then maybe, but its been forever since Khubi was able to play a lot of games during the reg season.
And I think with how the playoffs ended, and for the second straight time Luongo had a bad playoff series to end their run again I think he’s going to be on fire to prove himself this year.
Khabby played 202 games in the past four seasons whereas Roloson has played 217 so they both have their own health issues. Khabby also has a Cup ring; Roloson, though he came close, doesn’t.
Other numbers show them to be pretty similar, though maybe a slight nod in Khabby’s favor because he was on a Hawks team that was getting pummeled for at least two and half of the four seasons there:
Roloson’s 4 year GAA: 2.75
Roloson’s 4 year save : .907
Khabby’s 4 year GAA: 2.79
Khabby’s 4 year GAA: .904
Minor points perhaps, but if I were a long suffering Oil fan, I’d ignore the cost and view it overall as a better option than Roloson.
'Nucks Misconduct - Housing Swedish Millionaires Since 2000.
by Yankee Canuck on Jul 21, 2009 11:52 AM PDT up reply actions
Interesting that we are being picked as a “team on the rise”. I take pride in the morons back east who perpetually slot us into non-playoff teams, I don’t pay attention to any of the reporters or reports from TSN, Sportsnet (except Garry Valk) or the NHL.
I think that the Flames are the most complete team in the NW, they are tough, big and really responsible defensively. The Oilers are screwed, a terrible signing in Khabi for 4 years when Roli was there and could have been had for 2 years for similar money. People tend to forget that Roli was the team MVP last season and won the Oilers a handful of games that they didnt deserve. Khabi gets hurt and then what.
The Nucks are better than last year, no Sundin takes away, but Samuellson adds a lot. I expect monster seasons out of the twins, Luongo and Kesler. Throw in Edler and Bieksa steppin up, and we should be a good playoff team.
Yup, I agree on the Roloson point. And I agree that we are going to whoop ass too.
by Sean Zandberg on Jul 21, 2009 2:08 PM PDT up reply actions
I disagree about the Flames though. Are they sound defensively? Not really. Maybe under Brent Sutter they WILL be.
by Sean Zandberg on Jul 21, 2009 2:09 PM PDT up reply actions
I don’t know if we can count on Edler and Bieksa stepping up further. They are already good, I’m not sure if they’re going to get that much better. We need one more GOOD d-man and they I feel okay about our D. Right now I’m worried.
by Beantown Canuck on Jul 21, 2009 5:12 PM PDT up reply actions
I’m not. I think they are both going to have career years if they stay healthy.
by Sean Zandberg on Jul 21, 2009 5:20 PM PDT up reply actions
Winning the Northwest...
…doesn’t mean much this year. There will only be one or two NW teams in the playoffs this year (Vancouver and possibly Calgary).
Yeah, I’m calling it. What’s it to ya?
Nothing, I agree. Though I think that Calgary is not a possibly, it’s a yes.
by Beantown Canuck on Jul 21, 2009 7:17 PM PDT up reply actions

by 























